If I could I would probably give these shoes 3.5. I was so excited to find them in my size (I am a UK10 and struggle to find shoes that aren't mens colours - navy and black) and they fit really well and look great. However, they are not at all waterproof and never were from the start. (I have had them for a year.) They are at best shower proof. I actually wondered if I had got a dud pair. I suppose it's possible..... But I really like them all the same.bought for my 12 year old son (he didn't see the box). He's been using them for PE at school, no complaintsThey are the best shoes I have ever worn. So comfortable and supportive. Just the right amount of grip too.Love these shoes. Very comfy from the off, and brought for my summer walking adventures.Increíblemente cómodas. El agarre de la suela es muy óptimo. El diseño muy bonito. Yo uso un 39 y me cogí un 39 1/2. El pie queda sujeto pero sin apretar. He regalado otras a mi madre que tiene un juanete y no ha tenido ningún problema. Altamente recomendables.